About the Pipemaker

picture of me working on a pipe

Working with wood

I have enjoyed pipe smoking and collecting since a young lad of 16 and loved wood and working wood for as long as I can remember. I have picked up some skills with wood and tools, largely from my piano rebuilding work, and making a few pieces of furniture.

For many years I dreamed of making my own pipe one day, and I finally did. It was christened in as Etude #1, The Piano Tuner's Pipe. Many flaws and mistakes of course, but a wonderful and rewarding experience. I was hooked!

Since that first pipe I have dedicated nearly every spare moment to pipemaking and studying the work of the masters. My hope is to one day be among that elite group. For now, I'm hoping to soon be considered amongst the up and coming.

The following is from Bear Grave's Blog on SmokingPipes.com'
Introducing Scott ThileBear's Interview and Post-Interview

I think it’s safe to say that I never have, nor ever will be accused of being a “Will Rogers”. I have met men that I didn’t like and, though damned few, I have met pipe carvers with personalities that left me wondering how they could give away a stick of gum, much less sell a $1000(+) pipe. That said, the overwhelming majority of pipe artisans that I have known/interviewed, I have at least felt an affinity with, some (especially upon greater exposure) I have found to be incredibly cool to the point that it felt like I had discovered a kindred spirit. Then I began talking to a pipemaker, whom, within the first 45 minutes of what turned out to be about eight hours of conversation, I perceived such a degree of brotherhood, that it felt like I could burst into a room with a satchel, breathlessly blurt “Hide this!!”, run out, and know (after 5-7 years, 3 with good behavior) that the only change in its condition would be a patina of dust. That pipemaker is Scott Thile and, contrary to the Leo Durocher misquote, this is one nice guy that will never finish last.

Being the only person attached to marketing who was so out of touch with today’s pipe circuit that he didn’t know who Scott was, made me a natural candidate to conduct a ‘new to us’ interview. Having no preconceptions about the maker reduces the chance of subconsciously skewing questions in a manner that would emphasize preconceived strengths and downplay perceived weaknesses, in both the man and his craft.

While, in theory, it’s the interviewer’s job to rapidly establish a sense of ease, from the start it was Scott’s geniality and enthusiasm that set the tone for relaxed conversation. Scott began smoking a pipe because an older colleague whom he admired, Charles Wheeler, smoked one and it seemed ‘incredibly cool’. Mr. Wheeler smoked Dunhill's 'My Mixture 965' and (thus) so did Scott, and '965' is still a staple in Thile's tobacco rotation today. It wasn't until 2004 that the idea of carving a pipe started to have some appeal; being an adroit woodworker, pipe carving seemed like a natural extension of already present talents. In the tradition of most aspiring American carvers, he started with a kit, and (again) like most first time carvers, he was horrified with the outcome. Scott, as I would soon come to find out, is a man who understands where his strengths lie, and he had little doubt that those strengths would eventually produce fine smoking instruments. Though his training has been largely autodidactic, Thile has spent time with Todd Johnson and Bruce Weaver and cites Todd and Adam Davidson as influences. When asked what overarching aesthetic holds the most influence/fascination for his inner artist, Scott's answer was as interesting as it was succinct, "The Danish neo-classics as interpreted by the North American greats."

By the end of what (usually) would have constituted as the only interview, I had his basic biographical history, insights about his craft, visions as a pipemaker, plus a pleasantly daunting list of additional interests and passions which eerily coincided with mine. It turned out that we were within a couple of months of the same age, as enthusiastic about acoustic jazz as we were ambivalent about its ‘smooth’ cousin, and started smoking a pipe within about 45 days of each other. On a lark, as something of a fun test question to discover just how close some of our thinking processes worked, I asked. “Stuck in traffic, you notice a huge truck in front of you with a personalized license plate that reads “Stud19”. What’s your first thought?” “That there are another 18 idiots out there with ‘Stud” on their license plates?” Oh yeah, a fellow traveler on the highway of Snark. In addition, I came away with a ton of cool (and usable!) tidbits. Things like he has played the bass since he was young, continues to keep his hand in as a professional even today, and his son (Chris) is a very gifted mandolin player.

Thus armed, I came in the next morning, chest already puffing in anticipation of the praise that would be heaped on my head for the INCREDIBLE amount and quality of intel that I had gleaned from Scott. It was during the wait for the marketing meeting that my confidence started to shake and, of course, it was Adam with the jackhammer. “It turns out that Scott’s son is quite the talent with a mandolin” Adam reached into his desk and flipped a CD at me titled “Yo-Yo-Ma & Friends: Songs of Joy and Peace” Upon opening the trifold cover, there’s Chris Thile in the middle panel, holding his mandolin, surrounded by Diana Krall, “Sweet Baby” James Taylor, Allison Krauss, Renée Fleming, Josh Redman, Dave Brubeck…. “Oh Chris also has an impressive list of Grammy awards and nominations, and became a MacArthur Fellow in 2012 (think “John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation”) (cack!) “Well… did you know that Scott’s also a professional bass player?” “Google ‘Nickelcreek’, Bear” God help me, I did. (Channeling Ricky Ricardo) “Scoootty… choo gots some ‘splaning’ to dooo”

Then came the marketing meeting. Ted: “Took a look at the notes, pretty good job Bear. I think that you should also include that Scott Thile started and has maintained Pipedia at considerable personal cost and labor” (Pipedia: the number one repository of pipe knowledge in the world, a priceless resource from which I stolen… erm, ‘researched’ a fair amount of information, and yet never took the time to find out who created the treasure). “I think that level of passion and selfless support to the pipe community is something all of our customers can get behind”. Now sporting what Vietnam vets referred to as the “thousand meter stare”, I replied something like “Yup, mmmhmm, that they would”, and added “Call Scott” to my must-do list.

“Hey Bear, how the hell are ya doing?” “Pipedia” “Sure, what about it?” “You started and have maintained it” “Well… yeah” “Why didn’t you mention that?” “You didn’t ask” (…..) “You played bass on a CD that went Platinum and was nominated for two Grammys” “Only for a couple of tracks, and they never sent me the Platinum Award”. “Before we debate the merits of the designated pitcher, are you either; a: A Nobel Laureate, b: A leading cancer researcher with a major breakthrough awaiting FDA approval or C: An ultra-secret, high level ambassador who, unbeknownst to the world, has been manipulating the delicate threads which have kept the peace between the superpowers for decades?” (laughing) “No, no, and I’m a pipe maker”. “One more question?” “Shoot” “Are we still going to “meet for a beer and talk sedition”?” “You bet!”

Please don’t misunderstand, I was the cocky pratt who walked into a marketing meeting with only a partial glimpse of the immense talent that laid within a remarkable man and, to my mind, Scott’s combination of natural modesty and ‘just is’ mindset makes him all that more exceptional. After more than 33 years of association with pipe retail, I can declare that collectors will naturally gravitate to the carvers who not only create magnificent pipes, but who are extremely likable as well. Having described Thile’s work and having talked extensively with the man himself, I’m quite confident that this already popular carver will become a universal favorite.

Bear Graves: Media & Content Specialist

Rose & Pipe--reflection on a middle life passion


To the left is a shot of Etude # 8, one of my early efforts. The setting features my wife, Kathy's beautiful work from her rose garden.

Early one morning the sun was streaming onto my desk where my wife of 27 years had placed a beautiful arrangement. She is an avid and gifted gardener.

I was enjoying a cup of strong French Roast and looking at her work while also reflecting on how our lives have evolved. You know the drill, young couple in love, newlyweds, busy parents struggling to make a living and build a life-- now with a bit more time again. I thought how cool it is that she has time for gardening, and I have time for pipemaking.

It was then I grabbed the camera.

Where there's a will...

In the US it is difficult if not impossible to find a formal apprenticeship arrangement with a master pipemaker, and my situation would not have easily allowed for this, even if I had found one. As a result, I am primarily self-taught. But I have received a great deal of help from a dedicated group of pipemakers on the pipemakers forum, which can easily be considered a virtual school of pipemaking in and of itself. It's a fantastic resource! Several members of the forum have been an amazing inspiration and encouragement. I also learned a great deal and have been very encouraged from hands on evaluations of my pipes at pipe shows by some fantastic pipemakers and dedicated collectors. And finally, my pipe smoking friends, family, and customers are another great source of feedback.

A reflection on the tuning of pipes.

I am a piano tuner-technician and piano rebuilder by trade, as well as a musician. I love music and I find musical instruments and the materials they are made from beautiful and fascinating.

The musicians, and the musical forms and compositions I work with are a great inspiration to me. I hope to use musical elements and themes as inspiration in my pipe making. I also hope to use some exotic instrument materials as accents in my pipes.

In pursuit of the well-tempered smoking instrument (a piano tuner turns to pipemaking).

Equal temperament, the meerschaum pipe of tuning schemes, is a scheme of musical tuning in which the octave is divided into a series of equal stepspicture of me tuning a piano (equal frequency ratios). This has come to be the main tuning scheme for piano, and many other instruments. While equal temperament allows for completely free modulation between the keys, it comes at the expense of individual key color. I look at equal temperament as being the Meerschaum pipe of tuning schemes. Meerschaum does not contribute to the taste of the smoke like equal temperament does not add to the color of the various keys in music.

Well temperament is a term modeled on the German word wohltemperiert which appears in the title of J.S Bach's famous composition, The Well-Tempered Clavier. Bach is one my favorite composers and was also an avid pipe smoker. Recent research indicates the Well Temperament schemes used in Bach's time, and continuing into the late 19th century, preserved the character of each key, while also allowing for free modulation between the keys. You guessed it, well temperament is the briar of tuning schemes, well temperament adds its own unique color to the music, just as briar adds its own unique qualities to the smoking of tobaccos.

picture of me playing bassMy goal in making pipes (well-tempered smoking instruments)

My goal is to incorporate the individual esthetics and smoking characteristics of each piece of briar. Allowing the pipes to tastefully and subtly color the different tobaccos smoked in them while hopefully satisfying the aesthetic sense of the smokers they're made for.

In my personal collection many pipes end up being dedicated to one tobacco, or a family of tobaccos. Some I save for Virginias only, and others I mainly enjoy with heavy Latikia blends. Perhaps this is analogous to Just Intonation tuning, which is a tuning scheme completely optimized for music in one key, and Mean Tone tuning schemes, which allow for very limited modulation between keys. Sorry, I digress.

Thanks for checking out the site.

Please feel free to E-mail me with any comments, suggestions, or questions about my pipedreams: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.